REP fitness PR-4100 rack vs Rogue SM3 squat stand
This is a comparison between the Rep Fitness PR-4100 rack and the Rogue SM3 suqat stand. Follow the links for more details.
Rogue SM 3 Monster squat stand
The Rogue SM3 squat stand comes in at $759 and is one of the mid-range options for under $1000 from Rogue. Learn more in this review which was originally published in the Article "Which Rack to buy from Rogue for under $1000".
Overview of the SM3
The
SM3 Monster Stand is the flagship of the
Rogue Squat stands and comes in at a height of 2.82m. It is available in black and manufactured in Columbus Ohio. This is the squat stand for the big players who mean business.
The
SM3 it comes in at a height of 111''. The steel notes are 3x3 Gauge steel. The total footprint of the squat stand os 50''x54''. This unit does not need
to be bolted
to the floor as it comes with the flat foot design of
Rogue. It will be shipped
to you including J Cups,. You can choose from either a Single Skinny Pull up bar or a Fat/Skinny pull up bar.
This is probably one of the biggest squat stands that you can get in the market. If you like it big and your customers too, go for this beast. If you have a lot of basketball players to train, this might be the squat stand for you.
Pros of the SM3
If money is not an issue with you and needs a squat stand, you can not go wrong with this one. It is completely overbuilt, in a good way. Why do you like a Mercedes. Probably not because it is the cheapest way to get you from A to B. This purchase will make you happy if you have high ceilings and tall athletes.
Cons of the SM3
If you want
to use this for
powerlifting it might be the wrong choice.
To bench press safely you will also have
to get spotter arms on top of the squat stand. The
Spotter
arms tailor at 270$ and all of a sudden you reached the $1.000 dollar mark and might as well look into a full
rack.
Alternatives to the SM3
IThe
Rogue RM4 fortis rack is a viable full
rack option that comes in at roughly the same prize as the
SM3 when you count in the
spotter
arms. If you want
to powerlift and have no special reason for getting a 2.82m high squat stand I would recommend the fortis instead. You will have more options
to upgrade and a safer environment
to train in.
If you are not a basketball player an on a budget the SML2 might be an alternative. The SML2 saves you about 300$ compared
to the
SM3 for accessories or a
barbell. You still will get a squat stand
which is 92'' high. The SML 2 is compatible with the MOnster lite series of
Rogue.
If you are as tall as a basketball player and still want
to save money, the SML3 might be an option. Again you are saving roughly 300$ compared
to the
SM3 while you keep the height at 108''.
Overview and review of the REP fitness PR-4100 rack
This is an overview of the REP fitness PR-4100 rack including the pros, cons, and alternatives. This article was originally posted in which rack to buy from REP Fitness. Follow the links for more information.
Related articles
Overview of the REP PR-4100 Rack $429
The
REP PR-4100 is the folding version of the
PR-4000 rack that outbid the REP fitness rack product line. With this rack, you get two uprights, and the cross-members you need to build a rack that can be bolted to the wall with a folding mechanism. This is the ideal rack for a garage gym in which you still want to park or a floor space that should be transformed into a yoga or playroom after the use of the rack. Some of the specifications for this rack are:
-
Choose between 21.5" or 41" depth (from wall to the front outside of upright).
-
(1) pair of plastic-lined J-cups.
-
(1) easy-to-adjust 1.25" pull-up bar.
-
5/8" diameter hardware.
-
1" hole spacing in benching area.
-
2" hole spacing above and below bench area.
-
Uprights: 11-gauge steel, 3x3", 92" tall.
-
21.5" Dims: 18.5" inside length x 42.5" inside width.
-
41" Dims: 38" inside length x 42.5" inside width.
-
48.5" overall width.
This is a solid option to get a lower-cost folding rack of good quality. Especially with folding racks it nightmare sense to invest a few extra dollars as the folding action needs more attentional detail in production than a simple four post rack.
Pros of the REP PR-4100 Rack
-
Space efficient
-
Budget efficient
-
Reliable brand
The biggest plus of folding racks is that they can get out of the way when they are not needed anymore. If you only have one occasional user of the rack in the house O would seriously consider a folding rack.
The
PR-4100 is good on your purse from two perspectives. You are getting your rack from a company that imports their products from China and you are buying a product that uses less metal than a
PR-4000 or
PR-5000. This makes the
PR 4100 a smart buy. Especially if you are not planning on many upgrades and attachments.
Compared to Amazon resellers or TITAN fitness you will buy from a young brand that is still bending over backward to grow its customer base. You will get good, reliable service with this rack in most cases, that is why the price is a little higher than sourcing from Amazon or from TITAN.
Cons of the REP PR-4100 Rack
As this is a folding rack with smaller holes on 3x3 uprights your use of attachments will be very limited. Personally, I think the most you can really get out of a folding rack is a dip station and not much else, but that is just me.
If you buy from REP Fitness your rack will be produced and packaged in China and then send to a warehouse in the US. If that rubs your patriotic streak up the wrong way you have to buy from Rogue Fitness instead and pay the extra money American Labour costs.
My biggest con for a folding rack is that you still have to come up with some solution for storing your plates as you can not do it on the rack. Unless you keep it permanently in place which defeats the purpose. There are good wall storage solutions for plates but those involve more DIY.
Alternatives to the REP PR-4100 Rack
The Rogue RML3WC is what comes closest out of the Rogue fitness portfolio to you the
PR-4100. It has the same uprights with only slightly different drillings for the holes. Some say that the folding action on the RML3WC is a little smoother but that also hugely depends on where it is being installed and who did the job.
The
TITAN X3 folding rack is TITAN’s 3x3 upright folding rack. This is the best option for a low price while still having some proper customer support with it. Other options are Amazon resellers who just stuck produce to flip it for a small
margin in bulk.
The
REP SR 4000 is an alternative option if you believe in squat stands with a big base for stabilizing. I personally don’t but if you think that is a good idea the
SR 4000 is excellent value for money.
Conclusion for the REP PR-4100 Rack
I personally think folding racks are a great idea for home gyms that need to co promise. If you use your garage as a mechanic/workshop in parallel or own a fancy Sunday car, this is the right option for you.