TITAN X3 squat stand vs Rogue Collegiate half rack [Article, Video]
This is a comparison between the TITAN X3 squat stand and the Rogue Collegiate half rack. Follow the links for more details.
Overview and review of the Rogue Monster Collegiate Half Racks
Price: 1.160
This review was originally posted in the longer article "Which strength equipment to buy from rogue" in which you can read about 25 products of Rogue which cost more than 1.000$. The Rogue Monster collegiate racks are a good solution when you want to build along lane of racks with plates in the middle. See the details in this article.
What else to consider from Rogue
Overview of the Rogue collegiate rack
The
Monster Collegiate half rack is another special purpose rack and one of the newer developments in the Rogue portfolio. You get the full benefit of the design when you opt for the double rack option. This leaves the
plate storage in the middle of two training stations optimizing footprint and rack stations in a long line which can be accessed from both ends. In addition, the design makes it easy to switch between band/rope work and heavy lifts in the same session due to the prolonged sockets.
How many clients should the collegiate rack bring you?
If you think that the
Rogue Monster Collegiate will bring you 4 new clients who pay you 50$ on a 1-year retainer it is worth the investment. This will yield 2.400$ net new revenue against an investment of 1.160$. Adjust the numbers for your own gym accordingly.
Pros of the collegiate rack
Cons of the collegiate rack
There are not many cons to this low price monster rack except that you do not get a full rack to train in.
Alternatives to the collegiate rack
Here are some alternatives at a price point of 1.160$ to the
Collegiate rack:
With this rack, you get a nice full rack with special branding at a slightöly lower price than the
collegiate rack. This can be a good option when you want more space inside the rack to do your workouts.
This is an option that leaves you with a full rack and the option to choose your color. The disadvantage is that you get the
Monster LIte to make instead of the Monster base for your rack.
Conclusion
If you want a rack that is not too expensive and can be used inside and outside a rack for band work, this is the one to go for. It is also a good option when you have limited space and want o make maximum use of your setup.
Further reading
Overview and review of the X-3 Squat stand with pull up bar
The TITAN X3 Squat stand will put you back about $490. TITAN is well known for their very good prices compared to their competition and will get you started on your home gym. This review was originally posted in “which Titan rack to buy for under $500”
Overview of the X3 squat stand
The
X3 is a squat stand which boasts 3x3 steel tubes. It is, therefore, a very sturdy
squat stand compared to other 2x3 or 2x2 options. The X3 comes with Westside spacing in the lower part of the rack to allow for smaller increments on the bench press. The flat foot design saves you bolting it to the floor which makes it a very good option in some home gym scenarios. It also comes with spotter arms. The specifics and features of the
squat stand are:
-
3" x 3" 11 gauge steel uprights
-
Westside hole pattern through bench zone
-
2" hole spacing above and below.
-
1,000 + lb capacity
-
Pair of UHMW lined X-3 JHooks included
-
Double-sided gusset plates
-
Standard 1.25" Pull up bar included
-
Mounted at your preferred height.
-
Pair of X-3 Spotter Arms included
-
Height: 92"
-
Width: 49"
-
Depth: 48"
-
Product Weight: 203 lb
-
Finish: Black Power Coating
-
Floor Space: 16.3 sq ft (49" x 48")
This is as sturdy as they come as far as squat stands go.
Pros of the X3 squat stand
As with all TITAN equipment, the first thing to note is the competitive price. You will have a challenge to find a good quality 3x3
squat stand for the same price. A
squat stand also gives you the ability to drop weight easier than in a power rack. If you prefer the Olympic lifts over powerlifting this might be the better choice for you. A squat stand also saves space and can be easily transported.
Cons of the X3 squat stand
Especially for beginners, you have less protection. The spotter arms are fine and nice, but in practice, safety pins in a full rack are a lot more secure as you won’t miss them. The whole structure is also led likely to tip over if installed correctly. In addition, TITAN is known for inconsistencies on their finish.
Alternatives to the X3 squat stand
For almost the same amount of money, you can get a colored version of the
T3 rack. While the tubes are only 2x3 you will get a full rack in the color of your choice.
Another way to go is to save on the color to have more budget for different size options on the
T3 and maybe even adding some plate holders. The
T3 is available in a short and tall version to adjust the height. For depth, you can choose between 24” and 36”.
The
T3 folding rack saves you about $100 on the X3 and can be installed in your garage. If you only train on the weekends or two days a week, this is a good option so that you can still use the garage or basement for your car/ miscellaneous rubbish you think is important ( I have that stuff in my attic). The savings can be put towards a barbell like the blues city or Atlas bar.
Summary of the X3 squat stand
A great option for anyone planning on a home gym for Olympic lifting or a gym that still has a corner left and does not j ow what to do with it. If you get the
squat stand make sure you can store your plates somewhere separate.