Rogue dog bone pull up bar vs dinnie ring set
This is a comparison between the Rogue dog bone pull up bar and dinnie ring set including pros, cons, and alternatives. It was published first under which grip strength tool to get from Rogue. Follow the links for more details.
Overview and review of the Rogue Dinnie ring set
This is an overview of the Rogue dinnie ring set including pros, cons, and alternatives. It was published first under which grip strength tool to get from Rogue. Follow the links for more details.
Related articles
Overview of the Dinnie ring set
Price: $45
The
dinnie ring set is not for the faint-hearted. You will get bare metal rings which are anything but smooth. These have been modeled after the famous
dinnie stones in Scotland which have been a legend to lift among strongmen for decades. As such they are handmade from metal and show their raw finish. The specifics of these rings are:
-
Strongman Rings - Grip Strength, Ring Lifting Exercises
-
Sold In Pairs
-
Hand-Forged in Logan, OH
-
American Steel construction
-
Large and Small Size Options
-
No 2 Rings are Identical
You will get two rings, one small, one big. Use them wisely.
Pros of the Dinnie ring set
If you use these rings as handles for most of your lifts, you will not fail in competition on grip strength. Almost any kind of handle you will face in a strongman competition will be smoother and more forgiving on your hands unless it is an ancient metal like the handles of the dinnie stones themselves. If you want to lift these stones, the
dinnie rings re also the best way to prepare for it.
Cons of the Dinnie ring set
As these rings are not smooth and unfinished they will rip some calluses and hurt some hands. Just be sure that you have the kind of clients that take rawness over comfort in their training. Otherwise, you might get some puzzled looks or members canceling their subscription. As with most rings, it takes getting used to how to set up the straps and loop them to a carabiner to make it work.
Alternatives to the Dinnie ring set
The
gymnastic wooden rings might be the better choice if you want round handles for some lifts, but be easy on the hands. These can also be used for several calisthenics exercises.
The
Rogue echo rings are a more economical alternative to the gymnastic wood rings. If you buy in bulk these are the better option. If you buy for yourself tread you to the feel of wood. It's worth it.
If you are looking into the
Dinnie rings for strongman purposes you can also opt for the
Rogue ring power pin. This will be easier to set up for your lifts and be more forgiving on your hands.
Conclusion for the Dinnie ring set
The
dinnie rings are a very specialized application of strength. They can be fun, but can also turn into a pain in the backside when you do not know how to use them. If you are already familiar with working with straps and carabiners on your strength training, this is a nice addition to your arsenal. If you aren't, stay way clear of them.
Overview and review of the Rogue dog bone pull up bar
This is an overview of the Rogue dog bone pull up bar including pros, cons, and alternatives. It was published first under which grip strength tool to get from Rogue. Follow the links for more details.
Overview of the Bone pull up bar
Price: $85.50
This is a good tool that combines a sphere and a thick bar. If you want to save me eh and space it is a hood option for grip training.
Pros of the bone pull up bar
-
Compact design
-
Low price
-
Good grip
As with all the steel products from rogue the
dog bone is so one in its design and excellent in its execution. You get many grip variations on one compact surface to use in your home gym or commercial gym for a comparatively low price when you get the separate tools. As the finish is the same as for rogue
kettlebells and other metal you will also have a good grip.
Cons of the bone pull up bar
As this design is very compact it is very easy to be on a part of the
dog bone that is neither straight nor a
sphere, but somewhere in between.
Climbers might like this but for lifters, that is not really ideal. It will also be hard to use two
Dog bones in two weights so the assumption is that you will always lift one weight with two hands. This limits options compared to
cannonballs or
pinch blocks considerably that come in free moving pairs.
Alternatives to the bone pull bar
The
crown pull up bar is pricier and also needs to be attached to the
rack. So it assumes that you already have invested in a home gym whereas the
dog bone also can work by itself. That being said, if your main interest is pull-ups and hanging holds, the
Crown pull up bar is far superior to the
dog bone. The distinction between bar and
sphere is clearer. You also have different sized
spheres and angled bars for a truckload if pull up variations. If you have a
rack, spend the extra money, it’s worth it.
If you are looking into the
dog bone to increase your grip strength rather than improving your pull-ups than the
cannonball grips might be the better option. You get a pair of them for a lower price and they form perfect
spheres. As you can order them with carabiners and steals you can hook them up with many different weights to vary your training. This makes your training more symmetrical and does not assume that you always have both hands on the weight like with the
dog bone.
The conclusion to the bone pull up bar